Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports

10 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports of 2022

The joy in ice-cream makers is understandable by anyone who has experienced homemade ice cream at least once in their lives.

Therefore, if you intend to make quality ice cream from the comfort of your home, then you should probably invest in an ice cream maker.

We intend to show you around some of the best ice cream makers available in the market right now through this list of products.

Top 5 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports: Editor Choice

No matter the type of flavor you go for, these products have all the right features to ensure you get the best of anything you make; let’s get started then, shall we?

The 10 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports Review:

It’s essential to go for something which will allow you the freedom to play around with flavors. That’s why we have hand-picked 10 of these items, which will ensure you get the most out of them –

1. Cuisinart ICE21R Frozen Yogurt Automatic Ice Cream Maker

Frozen Yogurt Automatic
  • New mixing paddle makes frozen desserts and drinks in 20 minutes...
  • Large capacity makes up to 1-1/2-quarts. BPA Free
  • Double insulated freezer bowl eliminates the need for ice
  • Easy lock transparent lid with large spout makes adding...
  • Fully automatic with large ingredient spout for adding...

Let’s start by stating that when it comes down to making the best kitchen appliances, Cuisinart is one of the top brands. This ice-cream maker has its touch in the case of functionality and convenience.

One more great thing about this product, it comes in several different colors, among which you can choose the one that fits your place and other appliances more.

Making frozen food items can be complicated on several fronts; one of them is mixing them. But the included paddles help you get better mixtures when you’re using this product.

When it comes down to the capacity, it has a large 1 to 1½ quarts of holding capability. So, you can easily make larger batches of ice cream using this fantastic device.

Another essential thing to mention is the larger spout; this allows you to put in ingredients more comfortably without resistance.


  • Takes very little time to make drinks and desserts
  • Includes mixing paddles for better flexibility
  • Large capacity for larger batches
  • Transparent lid system for ingredient assessment
  • Automatic spout system


  • Bowl is not compatible with dishwashers
  • Cover can be slightly prone to cracking during impact

Buy on Amazon

2. Whynter ICM-201SB Upright Automatic Ice Cream Maker

Whynter ICM-201SB Upright Automatic
  • Self-contained frozen dessert maker that does not require...
  • Stainless steel housing; Reliable built-in audible timer
  • 2.1 quart (2 liter) capacity; -0.4ºF to -31ºF Cooling...
  • BPA-free stainless steel removable mixing bowl and churn blade...
  • LCD timer control; Motor Protection Function that shuts off to...

This ice cream maker is one of the best ice cream makers mentioned in almost all reviews. Its high-quality structure and functionality are an attraction for most users interested in buying one.

There are few variants of this product; we are talking about the base one. But the others offer an additional recipe book and even a great scoop to go with all your ice-cream endeavors.

One of the best components of this item is the built-in freezer. In most products, you would have to pre-freeze to get the result you want to get, but that is not required.

That freezing system comes in handy when you’re making frozen yogurt and many more things; it allows the work to be done much faster as well—making it relatively easier for you to operate.

In the case of cleaning, all the components of the device are removable. So, you don’t have to worry about cleaning the machine; you can just do it any time you want!


  • Built-in freezer system
  • 2 quarts storage capability
  • Removable components for better cleaning
  • Each to use a timer system
  • Motor protection system for damage prevention


  • Sound of the motor can be slightly overbearing
  • Automatic stopping system is slightly inconvenient

 Buy on Amazon

3. Cuisinart ICE-30BCP1 Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-30BCP1 Ice Cream Maker
  • SUPERIOR FUNCTIONALITY: This brushed stainless steel fully...
  • MUST-HAVE FEATURES: Large ingredient spout for easily adding...
  • INCLUDED: Comes with replacement lid, a double insulated freezer...
  • NOTES TO CONSUMER: Make sure your freezer is set to 0-degrees F...
  • LIMITED 3-YEAR WARRANTY: Refer to user manual for troubleshooting...

Cuisinart is bringing forward another fantastic product, which is among some of the best ice cream makers because of its heavy-duty motor system. It is capable of more rotation and better efficiency.

The body of the item is made of stainless steel, with a brushed texture. That gives it a matte look, which looks impressive among all the other appliances in your kitchen.

When you are making ice cream, the product needs to be able to mix several different ingredients altogether. Therefore, the larger sprout comes in quite handy.

It gives you more clearing when you want to make quicker mixtures and add multiple ice-cream things. Also, it will add better flavor to everything you create and the texture.

The bowl of the product is removable and easily cleanable. But the interesting part is the double insulated construction since that positively influences the performance of the bowl.


  • Easy to store design
  • Includes a fantastic recipe book
  • Larger spout works to improve mixtures
  • High power motor system
  • Double insulated bowl design


  • Doesn’t includes a built-in freezer system
  • Intensity of the freezing can be insufficient sometimes

 Buy on Amazon

4. Hamilton Beach Ice Cream Maker

Hamilton Beach Ice Cream Maker
  • Delicious versatility - Make ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard,...
  • Fully automatic - no stirring needed. Just add ingredients, ice &...
  • Over 20 recipes included - Try the recipes inside or create your...
  • Easy-lock lid - Easily fits on top and locks in place with a...
  • 4 quart capacity - The perfect size for families and special...

If you are looking for something versatile, something with which you can make many things, you should try this device out. Along with versatility, it has everything you might need.

Another great thing about this product is the automatic steering system. You won’t need to use an external paddle to mix any ingredient; it will work completely independently.

After the whole preparation system is done, it will automatically stop the entire process. This helps the motor retain some strength, making it last much longer in the long run.

Now comes the interesting part, the recipe book included with the package has more than 20 recipes. You can follow those and surely make some of the best ice-creams and add some of your own.

The lock-in lid is another critical component in the product since it will make sure there isn’t any mess when you’re making the ice cream, making the cleaning process easy.


  • Easy lock functionality on the lid
  • 20 different recipes in the recipe book
  • Doesn’t require any stirring
  • Compatible for making things other than ice-cream
  • High capacity of 4 quarts


  • Some of the rotating components can leave aluminum shavings
  • Churring noise inside can increase with extensive usage

 Buy on Amazon

5. Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker

Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic
  • Award Winning: Best self-freezing ice cream maker by WireCutter...
  • Stainless steel housing; Reliable built-in audible timer
  • 1.6 quart (1.5 liter); -0.4ºF to -31ºF Cooling temperature
  • BPA-free aluminum removable mixing bowl and churn blade for easy...
  • LCD timer control; Motor Protection Function that shuts off to...

Another fantastic addition from Whynter is one of the best ice cream makers available in the market. This makes sure making ice cream is much easier with its built-in functionalities.

One of the critical attractions would be the built-in compressor, which will allow you to make ice cream without needing any pre-freezing. You can just put all the ingredients in; everything will work automatically.

This also makes making yogurt sorbet much easier, as pre-freezing can require a lot of time to get done. So, you might want to lean towards the mentioned product.

When it comes down to the settings, the easy to set setting makes it relatively easy to use. You can set up a time, and it will follow that time, carrying out all the necessary functionality.

Moreover, the materials used on the build for the product are entirely free from contaminants, and that will also help keep your health intact even in extensive usage.


  • Includes a built-in compressor system
  • The mixing bowl can be separately stored
  • Cleaning process is easy
  • Aluminum is free from BPA
  • There are different settings to customize


  • Customer support can be non-responsive
  • Canisters can have a slight smell

 Buy on Amazon

6. Yonanas 988RD Deluxe Frozen Dessert Maker

Yonanas 988RD Deluxe Frozen
  • QUICK AND EASY TO USE - Within minutes, easily turn any frozen...
  • DELICIOUS VERSATILITY - Create your own healthy, vegan, keto, and...
  • EASY TO CLEAN - All removable parts are top rack dishwasher safe...
  • PERFECT SERVING SIZE - Make a single serving or enough for the...
  • PEACE OF MIND - Trusted brand for over a decade, 1 year limited...

Among all the products on this list, Yonanas ice-maker is one of the most uniquely constructed products. The dispersion system is the best feature, which comes in handy.

There are few different variants of the product, so you have the freedom to choose the one that you like the most. It comes in black, silver, and red color; here, we’re discussing the beautiful red one.

Another valuable feature is the included recipe book. Most books with these devices possess about 20 or more recipes, but this one has a whopping 75 recipes.

This unit can easily carry out all the recipes without anything else. Everything is adequately explained, so you won’t have any issues following the whole process.

After the whole process is done, you can easily disperse the ice cream straight from the product without scooping everything out. That makes it less messy for you!


  • Great dispersion system
  • Recipe’s book possesses 75 recipes
  • Capable of making vegan alternatives
  • Instructions are easy to comprehend
  • Several different color variations


  • Packaging can be slightly faulty
  • Blades are somewhat prone to clogging up

 Buy on Amazon

7. Nostalgia WICM4L Electric Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia WICM4L Electric
  • 4 quart capacity: great for party time or snack time, This unit...
  • NOSTALGIA ICE CREAM KITS: Unit works perfectly with all Nostalgia...
  • Cleanup is easy: with a plastic bucket that wipes away messes...
  • See-thru lid: to store Leftover ice cream in the freezer, a...
  • No manual effort needed: a powerful electric motor does all the...

Traditional ice-cream makers are great when it comes to their effectiveness. This product builds upon the conventional framework but also further improving the design for efficiency.

In aesthetics, this item possesses a wooden outlook, which intends to give you a clean and traditional vibe. There are several different variations of that, from dark wood to light wood.

When it comes down to the capacity, this product has a capacity of 4 quarts, which is more than most products on the internet which is excellent for smaller to larger batches.

Another great thing that makes this one of the best ice cream makers on the market is the Nostalgia kit. That allows you to make all the specialized nostalgia flavors.

The motor lock is the way to lock the blades in place, and it will secure the blades from damage. That will make the blades last much longer, and it will keep them stronger.


  • Traditional wooden design
  • Amazing holding capacity
  • Nostalgia kits help you make specialized mixes
  • Plastic makes cleaning easier
  • See-thru lid allows more transparency


  • Paddle connection with the motor can slightly problematic
  • There isn’t any automatic stopping system

 Buy on Amazon

8. Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic
  • SUPERIOR FUNCTION: Create two quarts of delicious frozen treats...
  • CAPACITY: Makes 2-quarts of your favorite ice cream, frozen...
  • MUST-HAVE FEATURES: LCD screen, 3 settings with multiple speeds...
  • INCLUDED: Ingredient spout with integrated measuring cup for easy...
  • LIMITED 3-YEAR WARRANTY: Refer to user manual for troubleshooting...

Having a proper timer system is essential since it will help you keep track of the things you’re making and make it much better for you. This product comes with that feature.

You can choose two units; you can choose the one without any timer and the one with a timer. We are going to discuss the one with the timer.

Moreover, the 2 quarts storage function is adequately sufficient to help you make larger batches of ice cream. It will also help you make smaller batches for sudden cravings.

The paddle is a very important component for the device since that will help the device process ice cream properly, and you get a much better mixed final result.

Additionally, there is another essential feature that we need to mention, which is the integrated measuring system. It will enable you to measure each of your batches much better.


  • Integrated measuring cup system
  • Count down timer includes auto shut off functionality
  • There are three different speed settings
  • Improved paddle movement reduce time
  • Perfect for making gelato


  • Capacity of the device can be slightly insufficient
  • Lid can have some fitting issues

 Buy on Amazon

9. VPCOK Ice Cream Maker

If you’re looking for a compact item with heavy-duty functionality, then this is the one you should go for since the device has all the right features.

The motor is one of the main attractions of this product since it can handle heavy activity. Along with that, the mixing paddle helps you scrape and aerate the food.

Moreover, the double-insulated freezing bowl is highly efficient at distributing adequate freezing to the ice cream you are making. It will also make the freezing process much quicker.

Due to the smaller design of the product, it is fairly easier to store. Larger products can be quite problematic when you are trying to store them in your kitchen.

Additionally, the transparent lid and removable compartments help you maintain what you’re making, and also it is easier to clean after you are done. You can just clean each component separately.


  • Easy to use detachment functionality
  • Healthier recipes are included
  • Transparent lid system
  • Perfect for gifts
  • Freezer bowl doesn’t require any external ice cubes


  • Device is not dishwasher compatible
  • Automatic steer mixing can be slightly inefficient


10. Costway Ice Cream Maker

Costway Ice Cream Maker
  • 🍨【Multi-Purpose Use】This ice cream maker is Incredibly...
  • 🍨【Large Capacity】This ice cream maker machine allows you...
  • 🍨【LCD Timer Control】The product is easy to operate, Just...
  • 🍨【Protection Function】This product has a reliable built-in...
  • 🍨【clean & Store Easily】The bowl and churn blade are...

When it comes down to technological advancements, this device rivals some of the best. It also has one of the unique designs in the market right now!

What’s impressive about this product? Well, one of the key things would be its versatility. Using this single item, you can make many items one by one, starting from ice cream to gelato.

Then this versatility is further enhanced with its capability to make larger batches of ice cream. You won’t have to repeat a process over and over again; you can just get whatever you want in one go.

The main controller framework is quite important if you want to get the best out of the product you are using. You can just easily control the timer using the LCD control frame.

After setting the timer, you really won’t have to pay any attention since it will automatically shut off after the timer runs out. You can set any time you want on the device.


  • Timer control is easy to operate
  • Best for larger batches of ice-cream
  • Has a built-in audio device
  • Motor has an auto shut off function
  • Package includes an ice cream scooper


  • Due to the larger size, it is hard to store
  • Touch system can come in unwanted contacts

 Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Select Ice Cream Makers

Best Ice Cream Makers

There are few different things you should make sure of before buying an ice cream maker. Some of these features are quite obvious; let us show you around –

a) Paddles

Among all the freezing properties, this is one of the most important since it will make sure the ice cream you make is smooth. In some instances, when you’re freezing the ice cream, it can form a harder ice bit.

The paddle will be able to break it all down, and it will make the ice cream much smoother. That will make your food much better tasting since too much icing can be pretty bad.

b) Size

Size is quite crucial for you to consider since it will make sure you get larger ice-cream batches. However, if you prefer, you can also get a smaller one; some are specifically designed for a single serve.

But one of the biggest issues of getting a larger device is that you might have difficulty storing them. Therefore, you should consider where you are keeping them, then buy the more convenient one.

c) Recipes and Instructions

The instruction manual is an important component of the device; along with giving you the complete instruction, it gives you recipes too. That’s why you need to make sure you get something that will have many recipes to play with.

Most of the devices include recipes of 20 or more, but some have more than 75+ recipes. So, you might want to go for a device like that since they will also have healthier options.

d) Cleaning

Most of the products are not dishwasher compatible, but you should go for one since that will make cleaning much easier for you.

Moreover, detachable components are also quite essential to consider. Therefore, you should try getting something that will help you clean properly and reach deeper corners.

Final Words

Most of the products listed in this review are designed to ensure you get the best out of them anytime you want. But among them, you should definitely try Cuisinart ICE21R; this is one of the best ice cream makers on the market.

This product has everything you need starting from efficiency to functionality. You can also try out Whynter ICM-201SB. Due to the built-in freezer system, this product is one of the best, but it can still lag behind Cuisinart in building quality.

Therefore, before you go for these products, you should try assessing what suits you the best!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top